HERALD COUNTRY SHIELD SEMI FINALIST – TOP 4

1998 Senior Boys Football

Probably the biggest “could have won it” team of all. 

Equal 3rd in Herald Sun Country Shield, losing a close Semi Final at Dandenong, with Back Pocket Shane Costantino picking up the team’s BOG Medal awarded by Coach Gary Michael.

The team featured one future AFL player in the midfield, plus 3 key forwards that were all already getting interest from AFL clubs.

Missing from the team were two of those 3 forwards – Year 12s Nathan Parker and Stuart Cooper.

Parker was a 196cm Murray Bushranger with draft prospects, who the Bushies didn’t allow to play. Fair enough considering what happened to Scott Thompson the year before. Parker played 1 AFL Reserves game for Carlton that year (kicking 1 goal), as well as for Melbourne.

Cooper was devastatingly banned from the side by Senior School Leadership due to school issues. In one of the great tales of our School Sport history, Coach Gary Michael recalls being tapped on the shoulder at the Semi Final game by North Melbourne full back Mick Martyn, asking “where’s Cooper?” North Melbourne had sent Mick to watch Cooper, with eyes on drafting him a fee months later. Gaz had to tell Mick he’d been left back in Wangaratta.

That decision to disallow Cooper from playing likely cost the team becoming Herald Country Shield champions, but also Cooper the chance of being drafted to the AFL. He would later be Rookie Listed to North Melbourne, but not for another 3 years.

Most involved, and anyone looking at the talent in this team, seem assured it would have won it all with Parker and Cooper, or any one of them.

There was other serious talent in the team.

Year 11 Jon McCormick was the one future AFL player. He had the year before won the McCormick Medal (League Best & Fairest, U17s Junior League) as a Year 10, to go with his Ken Farrell Medal (League B&F U15s) three years prior at Year 8. Two years prior as a Year 9, he played in the O&M U15 Schoolboys (equivalent to today’s V-Line Cup), and won the best player award. The following year (1999) he would finish 3rd in the Bushrangers B&F and of course go on to play 26 games for Carlton, come Runner-Up in the VFL Liston Trophy, and win an O&M Morris Medal. Most judge “Hopper” as someone that could have played many more AFL games, if not for injuries (particularly stress fractures in his feet) curtailing his ability of be fully fit while at Carlton.

Andy Murray was playing Murray Bushrangers that year, after dominating the O&M Thirds for Wangaratta Rovers earlier in the season. Two years prior he had won the 1996 McCormick Medal at Year 10, and three years prior played Schoolboys with McCormick. Son of the famous Bob, St Kilda Premiership player (1966) and St Kilda Team Of The Century Full Back, Andy is described by teammates that year as a freak who was as dominant in the Thirds as anyone they remember. Towering marks over the top of packs at Centre Half Forward, bombing goals from miles out, and playing like a man against kids. St Kilda had obviously been tracking him as a potential Father-son prospect.

Twelve of the team played in the 1998 Rovers Thirds Premiership a few months later – Year 12s Murray, Mark McCudden, Scott Semple, Adam Lamb, Troy Walker, Jeremy Norman, David Caldwell, Justin Tilson, Yusef Tekesic, Shane Costantino, and Year 11s Glen Hancock and Scott Challman.

Others were playing for the Magpies Thirds that year – Year 12s Karl Gadsen and Matthew Peterson, and Year 11s McCormick, Stuart Evans, Craig Tobin, Trevor Edwards, Simon Gamze, Adam Norris, and Joel Fisher.

Some had actually played Seniors for the Magpies during the year. Year 11 Evans debut in the Seniors, playing on the reigning Morris Medalist “Juice Kingston, and kicked 5. He had kicked 9 in a Thirds game earlier in the year. Evans had played O&M Schoolboys with McCormick and Murray, and would that coming summer almost make the final Murray Bushrangers squad, after kicking 4 in a later trail game, but being cut at the last step.

Year 12 Jacob Ryan was playing Seniors and Reserves for the Magpies. “Spanner” had moved from the Gold Coast to further his Football, and the charismatic character hit Wangaratta like a firestorm. He would later spend time on Geelong’s Supplementary List, and later win the 2008 Morris Medal playing for Corowa Rutherglen.

Two of the Year 11s, Gamze and Brian Tavare, had played in the 1996 O&M Schoolboys team two years prior.

HOW THEY LINED UP – POTENTIALLY:

B: Shane Costantino, Mark McCudden, Yusuf Tekesic

HB: Justin Tilson, Scott Semple, Matt Cameron

C: Jeremy Norman, Troy Walker, Adam Lamb

HF: Stuart Evans, Andy Murray, Adam Hicks

F: Dan Leary, Scott Evans, Glenn Hancock

RUCK: David Cavicchiolo, Jacob Ryan, Jon McCormick

INTER: Craig Tobin, Simon Gamze, Trevor Edwards, Scott Challman, Matthew Petersen, Matt Thewlis, Karl Gadsen.

UNAVAILABLE: Nathan Parker (Bushrangers), Stuart Cooper (School).

HOW THEY COULD HAVE LINED UP – AT FULL STRENGTH – 

B: Shane Costantino, Mark McCudden, Yusuf Tekesic

HB: Justin Tilson, Stuart Cooper, Jeremy Norman

C: Dave Caldwell, Troy Walker, Adam Lamb

HF: Stuart Evans, Andy Murray, Scott Semple

F: Glenn Hancock, Nathan Parker, Dan Leary

RUCK: David Cavicchiolo, Jacob Ryan, Jon McCormick

INTER: Matt Cameron, Adam Hicks, Scott Evans, Craig Tobin, Simon Gamze, Trevor Edwards, Scott Challman, Joel Fisher, Matthew Petersen, Matt Thewlis, Brian Tavare, Jud Mullins.